Why coordinating your family's investments as one portfolio helps clients keep more of what they earn
We recently hosted a live webinar on householding ("unified managed household" or "UMH") with Bill Martin, Chief Wealth Officer at Earned. Below is a summary of Bill's expert insights on the topic. You can watch the full recording of the webinar here.
By mid-career, a client's financial life rarely fits in one account. There is a 401(k) or 403(b) from the current employer, perhaps an old plan from a former employer, backdoor Roth IRAs, a taxable brokerage account, a health savings account, 529 plans, and a spouse's accounts from a different employer. Each account was opened for a good reason, and each may be managed perfectly sensibly on its own.
The hidden tax cost often comes not from bad investment decisions, but from portfolio decisions made in isolation:
No single decision was necessarily wrong. But taken together, they can create a tax bill that better coordination could have avoided.
In our After-Tax Alpha™ whitepaper, we made the case that after-tax returns are the only returns you can spend. This paper goes deeper on one of that framework's drivers, asset location and account coordination, because it is the least understood and, for many client families, among the most valuable. The remedy is simple to state: manage your family's accounts as one coordinated portfolio and let each account do the job it is best suited for. The industry calls this householding. I think of it as the difference between managing a collection of accounts and managing a family's wealth.
Reasonable Accounts, Unreasonable Taxes
The default approach, whether a family manages its own accounts or splits them among advisors, is to give every account its own miniature version of the target mix: the same 60/40 in the 401(k), the Roth, and the brokerage account. Call it the mini-me approach. It is simple. But it treats every account as identical, when the single most important difference between your accounts is how each one is taxed.
Householding takes the opposite view. Set one investment target for the household and let the household (not each account) be the unit of management. Each account is a puzzle piece: it does not need to replicate the whole picture by itself, as long as the pieces fit together to create the right household portfolio. Under this approach, your IRA might hold mostly bonds while your taxable account holds mostly stocks. Judged in isolation, each looks lopsided - even wrong. Judged together, the household sits precisely on target, arranged to keep more of what it earns. Judge the picture, not the pieces.
Two ways to manage the same household. Both hit the 60/40 target; only one uses each account's tax characteristics. Illustrative.
What the Coordination Is Worth
This is not a marginal refinement. Independent research has repeatedly estimated the value of getting asset location and account coordination right at approximately 50 to 70 basis points per year: Envestnet's Capital Sigma research attributes more than 50 basis points of annual value to asset-location advice, and Vanguard's Advisor's Alpha framework puts the figure at up to 70 basis points. Earned's After-Tax Alpha™ framework adopts that 50-70 basis-point range for its asset-location and account-coordination driver.
In plain English, a basis point is one-hundredth of one percent, so 50-70 basis points could mean keeping roughly $5,000 to $7,000 more per year, after taxes, for every $1 million invested - without changing what the household owns or how much risk it takes. The real power is compounding. As a hypothetical illustration: a $2 million portfolio earning 6% annually grows to about $6.4 million over 20 years; the same portfolio earning 6.6% - 60 basis points more - grows to about $7.2 million, a difference of roughly $770,000. The illustration assumes constant returns, no withdrawals, and unchanged tax treatment; it is illustrative, not a prediction or a guarantee.
Where the Hidden Costs Come From - and How Coordination Removes Them
Wash sales that cross account lines. Tax-loss harvesting creates a useful tax asset only if the loss remains deductible. Under the wash-sale rules, a loss can be disallowed when substantially identical securities are acquired within the applicable window: 30 days before or after the sale. The issue does not stop at the account where the loss occurred. IRS guidance specifically addresses replacement purchases in IRAs and Roth IRAs, where the tax consequences are especially unfavorable, and a spouse's account activity can matter as well. The typical failure is two individually reasonable transactions that conflict when viewed together. For example, a taxable account harvests a loss while a retirement account automatically reinvests into the same fund. Household-level visibility coordinates known trading activity before trades are placed. It cannot eliminate wash-sale risk from accounts or activity the manager cannot see, which is why held-away accounts, automatic purchases, and spouse-directed trading need to be part of the conversation.
The same harvested loss, with and without household-level coordination. Illustrative.
Investments living in the wrong accounts. Asset location asks a different question from asset allocation: not what the household should own, but where each investment should live. Investments that generate heavily taxed income - taxable bond interest, for example - may be better suited to tax-advantaged accounts, while tax-efficient stock exposure and municipal bonds fit naturally in taxable accounts, and the highest-growth assets often belong in Roth accounts, where qualified withdrawals can be tax-free. These are illustrations rather than universal rules; the right placement depends on returns, rates, liquidity, and plan menus. And location is rarely worth fixing overnight, as repositioning can trigger gains and cost. The better path is usually gradual, through contributions, withdrawals, and ordinary rebalancing.
Asset location in brief: the same investments, arranged by how each account is taxed. Illustrative, not universal rules.
Gains realized in the wrong place. When a household drifts off target, rebalancing means selling something. And where you sell determines what you owe. An important and often overlooked part of household-level tax management is deciding where gains and losses are realized, what we call capital-gains location.
A practical sequence is:
This is a decision framework, not a rigid rule. Capital-gains location can sometimes conflict with asset location. For example, an IRA invested entirely in bonds provides little room to rebalance stocks. And tax considerations should never take priority over appropriate risk, diversification, liquidity, or the financial plan itself.
Capital-gains location: a tax-aware selling sequence for household rebalancing. Illustrative framework, not a rigid rule.
Why Visibility and Consolidation Matter
Every technique above shares a prerequisite: someone has to see the whole board. An advisor can only coordinate the accounts and activity they can see and, where applicable, manage. When a household's taxable accounts, IRAs, Roth accounts, spouse accounts, and trusts are spread across multiple advisors, each manager may make reasonable decisions without knowing what is happening elsewhere. This lack of coordination can create the same hidden costs described throughout this paper: cross-account wash sales, duplicated or conflicting trades, weaker asset location, unnecessary realized gains, and missed opportunities to rebalance inside tax-advantaged accounts. Over time, the household's combined allocation may also drift away from its intended strategy.
Fragmentation is the norm, not the exception. SEI's 2026 research found that 88% of surveyed wealthy investors hold at least some assets away from their primary advisor, and tax savings were the most frequently cited reason investors would consider consolidating more assets with one advisor. The point is not consolidation for its own sake, and consolidating is not automatically appropriate in every situation; existing investments, services, costs, and other relationships all matter. The point is visibility and coordination: the more of the household an advisor capable of true household-level management can see and manage, the more complete the information set and the more effective the tax-aware coordination can be.
Not Yet the Industry Standard
It is fair to ask why, if the benefits are well documented, this is not simply how everyone manages money. The honest answer is that it is operationally hard. In SEI's research, advisors delivering household-level tax services reported spending roughly 48 hours per month on the related manual work. Orion's 2026 Advisor Wealthtech Survey found that 84% of advisors consider managing an entire household as one coordinated portfolio valuable, yet most of these advisors had yet to adopt unified-managed-household capabilities. Cerulli's 2026 managed-accounts research reaches the same conclusion directly: household-level management is an increasing industry priority, but the unified managed household is far from becoming the industry standard.
Although household-level tax management is receiving increasing industry attention, the technology and operating model required to implement it consistently are not yet standard across wealth-management firms. This is where newer technology changes the economics. Earned implements household-level management through tax-smart technology and coordinated trading services powered by Smartleaf, embedding the coordination into the everyday portfolio process - so that contributions, withdrawals, tax-loss opportunities, and drift corrections can be evaluated in the context of the whole household rather than one account at a time. With this technology, what was historically a labor-intensive service done by hand for a firm's largest relationships becomes a repeatable portfolio-management discipline that can be applied across a broader range of client wealth levels.
The Limits and Measurement of Householding
Householding is not equally valuable for everyone. A resident with a single 403(b) has nothing to coordinate yet. A household whose wealth sits almost entirely in retirement accounts will find location decisions largely moot until taxable wealth grows. And the benefits scale with higher tax brackets.
The value of tax-smart household management also needs to be measured carefully. Tax benefits are estimates, not guaranteed results. What an investor actually saves depends on their tax situation, investments, and the accounts included in the analysis. Tax-smart investing is most credible when its trade-offs are acknowledged, and its value is demonstrated through transparent reporting of tax savings and deferral at both the household and account levels.
No client has ever walked into our office asking for a unified managed household. They ask a simpler question: after everything, what will I actually keep? Householding is the answer to a question you already have. Your accounts may be separate, but your financial life is not.
Managed one at a time, reasonable accounts quietly produce unreasonable taxes. Managed together, those same accounts can reduce unnecessary taxes and leave more wealth working toward your family's goals.
Learn more: for a deeper discussion, watch the householding webinar I recorded with Smartleaf co-founder Jerry Michael here.
|
Key Takeaways
|
Sources & Notes
Earned. Earned After-Tax Alpha™ whitepaper (2026) - framework positioning; Driver 2 (Asset Location & Account-Coordination Alpha) value estimate of 50-70 basis points annually.
Asset-location research. Envestnet | PMC, “Capital Sigma: The Sources of Advisor-Created Value” (2019) - attributes more than 50 basis points of annual value to asset-location advice. The Vanguard Group, “Putting a Value on Your Value: Quantifying Vanguard Advisor's Alpha” (2020) - attributes up to 70 basis points to asset location. Both based on general investor populations.
Industry adoption. SEI, proprietary surveys of 518 financial advisors (January 2026) and 302 high-net-worth investors, announced September 10, 2026 - 88% of investors hold some assets away from their primary advisor; tax savings the most-cited consolidation motivator (46%); 49% of advisors able to quantify household portfolio-management benefits; ~48 hours/month of manual household-level work. Orion, 2026 Advisor Wealthtech Survey (571 advisors, fielded December 2025) - 84% value managing an entire household as one coordinated portfolio; 42% plan to adopt or expand UMH capabilities over five years. Cerulli Associates, The Cerulli Edge-U.S. Managed Accounts Edition, Q2 2026 (The Unified Managed Household Issue) - UMH an increasing priority but not yet the industry standard.
Tax authority. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 550, Investment Income and Expenses, “Wash Sales”; IRS Revenue Ruling 2008-5 (wash sales involving purchases by an IRA or Roth IRA).
Author materials. Bill Martin speaker notes, Smartleaf householding webinar (2026); Earned Outcomes investing chapters 3.2-3.4 (draft) - voice and framework consistency.
Important Disclosures
Earned Wealth does not make any representations as to the accuracy, timeliness, suitability or completeness of any information prepared by any unaffiliated third party, whether linked to or incorporated herein. All such information is provided solely for convenience purposes only and all users thereof should be guided accordingly. We are neither your attorneys nor your accountants and no portion of this material should be interpreted by you as legal, accounting or tax advice. We recommend that you seek the advice of a qualified attorney and accountant. Investing involves market risk, including possible loss of principal and investment objectives are not guaranteed. An affiliate, Earned Wealth Advisors, provides wealth management services and is not an insurance broker although some representatives are licensed insurance agents and in such capacity may recommend the purchase of certain insurance-related products on a fully disclosed basis. These individuals are compensated for the sale of any insurance-related products, which presents a conflict of interest. No client is under any obligation to purchase any commission products from a representative of Earned. Clients are reminded that they may purchase insurance products recommended by Earned through other, non-affiliated insurance agents. © 2026 Earned Wealth Advisors, LLC. All rights reserved